BMW 1 Series vs Holden Astra

The 1 Series costs less to run, by the official figures: about $20 a year less in the US.

BMW 1 SeriesHolden Astra

Side by side

Specs are for each car's newest version. The better figure is in green.

BMW 1 SeriesHolden Astra

A typical year's fuel

United States
$1,375 (better)
$1,396
New Zealand
$1,940 (better)
$1,970
Australia
$1,465 (better)
$1,488
United Kingdom
£1,118 (better)
£1,135

Official figures

Uses
39 mpg (better)
39 mpg
Also
6.0 L/100km (better)
6.1 L/100km
On a full tank
518 miles (better)
490 miles

Space

Seats
5
5
Cargo space
13.4 cu ft
–
Length
170 in
172.7 in
Weight
3,180 lb
2,870 lb

Engine

Engine
1.5 L 3-cylinder turbo petrol
1.2 L 3-cylinder turbo petrol
Power
138 hp (better)
129 hp
Torque
162 lb-ft
177 lb-ft (better)
Gearbox
7-speed dual-clutch
6-speed manual
Drive
FWD
FWD

Safety

ANCAP
★★★★★
★★★★★
Euro NCAP
★★★★★
–
Airbags
6
6

A typical year: New Zealand 11,000 km (Ministry of Transport's average for a light vehicle); Australia 11,100 km (ABS Survey of Motor Vehicle Use average); United Kingdom 11,265 km (DfT National Travel Survey average of about 7,000 miles); United States 21,726 km (FHWA average of about 13,500 miles). Real costs depend on how and where you drive. Work out a particular trip.

1 Series or Astra?

Which is cheaper to run, the BMW 1 Series or the Holden Astra?

The BMW 1 Series: about $20 a year less in the US than the Holden Astra at today's average prices and a typical year's driving.

Which uses less fuel, the BMW 1 Series or the Holden Astra?

The BMW 1 Series, at 6.0 L/100km (47 mpg UK, 39 mpg US) to the Holden Astra's 6.1 L/100km (46 mpg UK, 39 mpg US), by their latest official figures.

Which has the bigger boot, the BMW 1 Series or the Holden Astra?

The BMW 1 Series, at 379 L to the Holden Astra's 360 L, for their newest versions.

Each on its own

Other comparisons

What will the drive cost?

Roadtrip works out the fuel or charging cost of any drive for your exact car, finds the cheapest stations on the way, and splits it between everyone in the car.

Rated 4.7 by drivers · 700,000 downloads

The Roadtrip app showing a drive into London that costs £4.81 each, with fuel prices along the way